Home » News » American Idol 2011 Top 4 Song List Spoilers

American Idol 2011 Top 4 Song List Spoilers

Posted by on May 11, 2011 at 9:21 AM EST

american idol final 4The American Idol Top 4 will have to sing songs written by Jerry Lieber and Mike Stoller tonight (May 11, 2011) and here are my song predictions.

With only four contestants left on American Idol, the top 4 can make no mistakes as we get closer and closer to the finale. Tonight’s “Lieber & Stoller” theme should be rather interesting as the Idol hopefuls have quite the selection of songs. Top that off with Lady Gaga as the mentor and we should be in for one hell of a show. Who will prove they are worthy of being the next American Idol?

We all know that the American Idol producers have banned audiences from live rehearsals to stop the song list leaks and spoilers. That’s ok though, as always we here at Robot Celeb will attempt our own song list predictions. Here are the “Lieber and Stoller” songs that I think the Idol final four will sing tonight: (Remember these were all written by Jerry Lieber and Mike Stoller for various artists)

Scotty McCreery – “Jailhouse Rock” by Elvis Presley – This one is pretty much a no-brainer. I mean the kid loves Elvis and I’d love to see Scotty rock out while adding his country twang to this classic.

James Durbin – “Love Potion #9” by The Coasters – Come on James! Do something completely off the wall tonight and prove to American you want to win this thing. I’m convinced it will come down the Durbin & Reinhart in the finale. Can Durbin steal the show tonight?

Lauren Alaina – “Charlie Brown” by The Coasters – You know, I don’t know why but when I saw the title of this song, I instantly thought Lauren. It’s probably better suited for Scotty and James but Alaina needs to do something drastic to stay in the competition and if she can make this her own, it could be a hit!

Haley Reinhart – “There Goes My Baby” by The Drifters – I’d like to see Haley add her sexy, jazzy voice [growling included] to this hit. She’s been stepping her game up week after week and I think she is a real contender to win American Idol.

These are my song choices for what the Top 4 American Idol contestants should sing tonight. Tune in 8|7c on FOX to see what advice Lady Gaga gives them and to see how wrong my predictions were! Comment below with your own song predictions on what you’d like the final four to sing.



(9) Readers Comments

  1. i would like to hear haley sing trouble by elvis presley or i’m a woman on her own spin like whar she’ve done in god bless this child and moanin’,with casey abrams in their duet.

  2. James/Haley finale will never happen. Scotty is the guy to beat. so your feeling or whatever is more like a dream. James and Haley neither one deserve to be in the finale.

    • Don’t under estimate Haley. I hope her talent proves of lot of haters wrong!!

  3. James will be in the top 3, Lauren will go home leaving Haley and Scotty. James will go home next week. Haley and Scotyy to the top. Haley will win.

  4. oops Scotty and Haley to the top, Haley will win this year…as much as I want James to win…just won’t happen for the rocker…too bad…but all will have a nice singing career.

  5. I wouldn’t be so sure of yourselves if I were you.
    There have been lots of surprises on American Idol. I think Scotty will be in the top two and he deserves it.
    The boy has some pipes and of all of them he’s the one I could listen to on the radio all day. Heavy metal is NOT my cup of tea, nor that of anyone I know. Lots of people think it will be Scotty and Lauren in the end. I’ve
    learned over the past 3 seasons not to be too sure what will come down. I loved Kris Allen and I loved Casey James. I read that Casey has turned Nashville upside down and his album will be out soon. He toured with Sugarland this spring and opened for them in 8 cities. He’s written several songs himself that will be in his album and they are pure Casey.

  6. I believe that Lauren will go next….she’s not gaining fans and it looks like, from various AI sites, that some of her original fans have lost interest and started supporting other contestants.

    That leaves James, Scotty, and Haley. And while Haley is my favorite contestant this year and she’s made a lot of progress, I think her charge came too late in the game for her to win. So I think Haley will come in third.

    Now between James and Scotty I see Scotty winning over James. I have a soft spot for James because I also have Asperger’s syndrome but the rocker just doesn’t win on Idol. The fresh-faced, down-home, cute and cuddley always wins. I think James and Haley will have good careers, but I do think Scotty will win.

  7. LAUREN WILL WIN!!!!!!

  8. Hailey needs to go. She growls way too much and now it is time for her to go growl somewhere else. Go Scotty!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.